Bring them home
The sooner we get out of Afghanistan, the better.
Not a single legitimate national interest is served by our continued presence there. The recent atrocity at Fort Hood should, if nothing else, demonstrate the idiocy of “fighting them there so we don’t have to fight them here”.
The only stakeholders who benefit from continuing the war are military contractors — and, outrageously, the Taliban, who now collect by some estimates up to a billion American taxpayer dollars a year in protection money.
This isn’t an Obama thing; this Chicago-style graft has been part of the way things are done in Afghanistan since we invaded eight years ago.
The extortion money is paid by local contractors hired by the US military and Western aid agencies to deliver supplies and equipment along dangerous overland routes controlled by the Taliban. The price for leaving convoys alone is tacked onto invoices, which adds up to 20% to the cost of doing business in Afghanistan.
Stop and think about that. The best-trained, best-financed, best-equipped soldiers in the world depend on bribes paid to the Taliban for the supplies they need to fight the Taliban.
And is it crazy to think that the money the Taliban earns from its protection scheme might be paying for the stuff they use to kill American soldiers?
We’re not fighting a nation-state, we’re at war with “terror” — a tactic. The Taliban are cockroaches in a tenement. Spray here, they scuttle next door. Spray there, they move downstairs. Time is on their side; death is no deterrent and they don’t fit strategy around political campaigns.
Military occupation won’t bring the country under control. For most people, behavior serves rational self-interest. In Afghanistan, rational self-interest means living for the day that the US leaves and the Taliban returns to exact revenge on collaborators.
Now, there is a plan to achieve “victory” as it’s been defined by neocons, but no American president will ever adopt it. Very simply, to win, we must do to Afghanistan what William Tecumseh Sherman did to the Confederacy in 1864 — burn a murderous swath across that unforgiving land until its people are more afraid of us than they are of the Taliban.
Until that day, which will never come (nor should it!), there is no hope of victory in Afghanistan.
The best — or, more accurately, the least worst — solution for the United States is to grit our collective teeth and get out. Delaying only makes the ultimate end more painful and humiliating.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Derek on December 1, 2009 at 11:43 pm, and is filed under Column. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
No trackbacks yet.
Times got White House OK on WikiLeaks story
about 14 hours ago - 1 comment
Alex Pareene raises a good question about the WikiLeaks Afghanistan war documents at Salon.com. The New York Times reporters who had semi-exclusive access to the files briefed the White House before publishing their story, and they say the administration praised their careful handling of the information. The White House did not, it appears, tell the
To boldly go where no man has…oh, wait, it says “Mecca”
about 3 weeks ago - 1 comment
My eyes have just rolled up into my head. Just when I start to cut President Obama some slack, a story like this comes along. You’d think our space agency’s prime directive would be to, you know, explore space. Under the Obama administration, however, it seems the mission is a bit more down-to-Earth: NASA Administrator
Column: Appoint For Us a King
about 4 weeks ago - 1 comment
In a development little noticed by the American public, President Obama’s subordinates have quietly let it be known that he reserves the right to have American citizens overseas assassinated. Not imprisoned. Not spied upon without a warrant. Killed in cold blood with no oversight whatsoever. Read the rest at Hearken the Watchmen.
The big question
about 1 month ago - 1 comment
Glenn Greenwald has another excellent column at Salon.com on the imperial presidency. Where is the outcry from so-called conservatives over President Obama’s claim of authority to order the assassination of American citizens without oversight of any kind? That’s right. This administration has a secret hit list of “dozens” of American citizens considered a threat. Aside
McChrystal knew what he was doing
about 1 month ago - 4 comments
Gen Stanley McChrystal didn’t rise to his position in the Army by being an idiot. He had to know what would happen when he allowed himself and his staff to speak freely around a reporter, especially one writing for a publication like Rolling Stone. So this explanation of “poor judgment” just doesn’t wash. Anyone over
VFTB 045: Report From the Last Days Conference
about 3 months ago - 3 comments
THE LAST Days Conference is now history, and everyone who attended would agree that it was a powerful experience. An impressive group of speakers each contributed a piece to the puzzle that is the timeline of the countdown to the end of the age.
VFTB 044: Paul & Phillip Collins — Obama, Transformer or Technocrat? / The Information Cartel
about 3 months ago - 2 comments
BARACK OBAMA is on a political roll, finally getting his health care reform bill and preparing to push through (equally unpopular) legislation on climate change and immigration reform. But can President Obama — or any president — really offer change?
Obama out of touch
about 6 months ago - No comments
And even while he says he gets it, the president doesn’t realize how out of touch he is: “If there’s one thing that I regret this year is that we were so busy just getting stuff done and dealing with the immediate crises that were in front of us that I think we lost some
History repeats: Obama = Hoover
about 7 months ago - No comments
From the Mises Economics Blog: “My main message in today’s meeting was very simple: that America’s banks received extraordinary assistance from American taxpayers to rebuild their industry and now that they’re back on their feet, we expect an extraordinary commitment from them to help rebuild our economy,” President Obama said after the meeting. In the
This explains a lot
about 8 months ago - No comments
Since over 80% of Americans work in the private sector, how is it that President Obama found so few with private sector experience worth appointing to key economic Cabinet posts?



about 7 months ago
in a word, “yes”.
Derek, if you recall, we home school in this home. this morning, Megan and I were in World History class, and at the point of studying WWI. I am an engineer, no student of history. but when they were describing the Treaty of Versailles, I closed the book and told my daughter, “looks like they created Hitler right about here.”
in the very next paragraph, they started to explain how this aggressive, vengeful accord had given legs to the hatred of Germans for the rest of Europe, and how Adolf had used that to accumulate power.
you don’t need to be Hari Seldon to see that people are predictable, and the more people in the group, the easier it is to plot their coursed in advance. the hard part is to see past your own preconceptions. or should I say “misconceptions:?
we know how many American soldiers are in Afghanistan, despite our government’s inability to count. there is no number for the Taliban. roaches are easier to kill because if you CAN get the last one, it would be the last one. Talibanians ( coined that on meself, on the spot, this spot ) are products of spontaneous generation, like they used to think fruit flies were. it is a decision made in the mind of an individual, one mind at a time, and the moniker is but a convenience.
evil is vile, and proliferates without copulation.
or as Paul, I think it was Paul, once wrote, “we wrestle not with flesh and blood, but powers and principalities.”
God’s blessings upon you and yours.
roy